Keywords
multi-discipline expertise
multi-discipline construction
technical and economic expertise
How to Cite
Abstract
The construction industry is one of the priority sectors of the economy and has a great social significance. Despite the implementation of the state policy on counteracting criminal offenses in the budgetary sphere, their level remains significant, especially in such priority sectors as construction, reconstruction and repair of state facilities.
As expert practice shows, recently, the number of expert studies related to the determination of the cost of actually executed construction work has increased.
Crimes in the field of construction have recently been characterized by a complex mechanism of accomplishment. During their investigation, the investigators have tasks whose solution requires the application of specialist knowledge in various fields, including accounting, engineering and construction, etc.
As analysis of investigative practice shows, in the investigation of crimes in the field of construction, a multi-discipline forensic-economic and construction-technical expertise is conducted.
Multi-discipline examination should be appointed when the solution of the questions posed is impossible as a result of several consecutive examinations.
There is an integrated examination, in the production of which the solution of the problem is impossible without the simultaneous participation of specialists in various fields of knowledge and formulation of their general conclusion. Multi-discipline examination is carried out by at least two experts from different fields of knowledge or different areas within one area of knowledge.
The article analyzes the peculiarities of the process of carrying out complex construction-economic researches and examinations, reveals the main tasks of the complex judicial building-technical and economic expertise, as well as proposes a general algorithm for the implementation of a multi-discipline forensic engineering-building and economic expertise.
The authors of the article agree that in most cases, the appointment of a multi-discipline construction, technical and economic expertise is the most efficient, methodologically correct way to the solution of expert tasks, when obtaining a reliable answer is guaranteed only by a general generalization of the results of the application of basic expert knowledge and methods.
References
Bashkirov G. B. , Zavdoveva I. G., Baranov P. Yu. Osobennosti naznacheniia i provedeniia sudebnykh kompleksnykh stroitelno-ekonomicheskikh ekspertiz po opredeleniiu stoimosti stroitelno-montazhnykh robot. [Features of the appointment and conduct of multi-discipline forensic economic construction expertise to determine the cost of construction and installation of works.] URL:http://www.hniise.gov.ua/user_files/File/sbornik/2014/PDF/59.pdf [in Russian].
Zapototskyi A. Osoblyvosti pryznachennia sudovykh ekspertyz pid chas ustanovlennia obstavyn, yaki maiut znachennia v protsesi rozsliduvannia zlochyniv u sferi budivnytstva. [Features of the appointment of forensic examinations in determining the circumstances that are relevant in the process of investigating crimes in the field of construction.]. Pidpryiemnytstvo, hospodarstvo i pravo, Kryminalnyi protses, 6/2017 [Entrepreneurship, Economy and Law, Criminal Procedure, 6/2017] pp. 173–175 URL: file:///C:/Users/%D0%9F%D0%BE%D0%BB%D1%8C%D0%B7%D0%BE%D0 B2%D0%B0%D1%82%D0%B5%D0%BB%D1%8CDocuments/40.pdf. [in Ukrainian].
Ekspertyza u sudochynstvi Ukrainy: nauk.-prakt. Posib [Examination in the legal proceedings of Ukraine: science-practice manual]. Kyiv, 2015. 504 p. [in Ukrainian].
Lysenko, A. M. Ekonomichni doslidzhennia operatsii, poviazanykh z vykonanniam budivelnykh robit iz zaluchenniam biudzhetnykh koshtiv [Economic research of operations related to the execution of construction works with the attraction of budget funds]. URL: http://www.hniise.gov.ua/user_files/File/files/2008.pdf [in Ukrainian].
Metodicheskoe pismo (1972). «Ob osobennostiakh provedeniia sudebno-bukhgalterskikh ekspertiz v stroitelnykh organizatsiiakh» [Methodical letter ‘On the peculiarities of conducting forensic accounting examinations in construction organizations’].Moscow, 35 p. [in Russian].
Nakaz Ministerstva yustytsii Ukrainy ‘Pro zatverdzhennia Instruktsii pro pryznachennia ta provedennia sudovykh ekspertyz ta ekspertnykh doslidzhen ta Naukovo-metodychnykh rekomendatsii z pytan pidhotovky ta pryznachennia sudovykh ekspertyz ta ekspertnykh doslidzhen’ vid 08.10.98 No 53/5/ [Order of the Ministry of Justice of Ukraine ‘On Approval of the Instruction on the Appointment and Execution of Forensic Expertise and Expert Investigations and Scientific and Methodological Recommendations on the Preparation and Designation of Forensic Expertise and Expert Investigations’ of 08.10.98 No. 53/5/].URL: http://zakon.rada.gov.ua. [in Ukrainian].
Sait Derzhaudytsluzhby [The site of the State Service]. URL: http://www.dkrs.gov.ua/kru/uk/publish/article/144094. [in Ukrainian].
Skalozub, L. P., Vasylynchuk, V. I., Slyvenko, V. R., Duchenko, T. V. (2009). Zbirnyk metodychnykh rekomendatsii z vykryttia ta dokumentuvannia zlochyniv u biudzhetnii sferi: metod. rekomendatsii iz zapobihannia zlochynnym proiavam pid chas zdiisnennia derzhavnykh zakupivel tovariv, robit ta posluh[Collection of methodical recommendations on the disclosure and documentation of crimes in the budget sphere: method. recommendations on prevention of criminal manifestations during the state procurement of goods, works and services]. Kyiv. [in Ukrainian].
Simakova–Iefremian, E. B. Dysertatsiia Teoretyko- pravovi ta metodolohichni zasady kompleksnykh sudovo-ekspertnykh doslidzhen [Dissertation Theoretical and legal and methodological principles of complex forensic research].URL: http://nauka.nlu.edu.ua/download/diss/Simakova/d_Simakova.pdf [in Ukrainian].
Palamarchuk, O. O., Bulva, A. V., Namestnikov, R. I., Vorobiova, O. Yu. Vykonannia budivelno – tekhnichnykh ekspertyz shchodo vyznachennia obgruntovanosti zastosuvannia pidvyshchuiuchykh koefitsiientiv [Implementation of construction and technical expertise to determine the validity of the application of increasing coefficients]URL: file:///C:/Users/%D0%9F%D0%9A/Downloads/Tpsek_2011_11_76.pdf [in Ukrainian].
Ruvin, O. H. (2014). Rozrobka zmistu ta struktury ekspertnykh metodyk: zmist, struktura, oformlennia (z urakhuvanniam mizhnarodnykh standartiv system upravlinnia yakistiu, adaptovanykh v Ukraini): metod. Rek[Development of the content and structure of expert methods: content, structure, design (taking into account international standards of quality management systems adapted in Ukraine): methodical recommendations]. Kyiv, 76 p. [in Ukrainian].